I’m not RanzigFettreduziert, and I don’t know much about PopOS, but…
- Rolling release is awesome.
- Amazing documentation.
- Helpful user base. (The forums are great.)
- Does pretty much nothing that you don’t specifically tell it to. (Like, very little is installed without your express say-so, for instance.)
- Customizeable as fuck.
- Doesn’t making things harder by trying to hide the “hard parts” from you.
- Doesn’t take days to install Libreoffice like Gentoo.
- AUR is great for software that isn’t available in the official repos. (Always review the pkgbuild, but practically everything is there.)
- Very up-to-date (even cutting-edge) on everything.
- And surprisingly stable given how cutting edge it is. (That said, I’ve never run a keyword-unmasked system.)
- Definitely will teach you a lot.
- Very actively developed.
Downsides:
- Learning curve. (Definitely not as bad as, say, Gentoo, though.)
- You’d definitely have to get really comfortable with the command line. (Arguably as much a good thing as it is a downside.)
- The biggest exception to the “customizeable as fuck” bit is that you’re stuck with SystemD, which is practically a whole OS. (And Artix (Arch but with a choice of init systems) is… kinda janky last I tried it.)
- Support for non-x86 (like ARM, for instance) is abysmal.
It’s kindof the second-most hardcore OS out there after Gentoo. (Nobody actually uses LFS as a daily driver, so I’m not counting that for this.) It’s the sort of OS that will teach you a lot and let you get down in the guts. But also avoids a lot of the downsides of Gentoo by remaining a binary OS.
Yeah, I know about the binary repositories. I’m running Gentoo as well (on one box with the intention to expand to other machines), but haven’t had occasion to use the official binary repositories yet.
I imagine I’d probably only ever use them if I wanted to install something temporarily. Install LibreOffice, view a file, uninstall. Just seems weird to have one package compiled with different USE flags than the whole rest of the system.
And, the compiler optimizations definitely aren’t why I use Gentoo. Probably more than anything, I’m sick of SystemD. And Gentoo feels a whole lot more “under my control” than Arch. (Arch is great for the most part, don’t get me wrong. I just like what Gentoo has to offer.)